Cheyenne and I
You had lunch at my work
And you asked for my number
You lied when you said I was cute
I could've lied
I could've said I was taken
You must've mistaken me
For some other guy in the room
But you gave me your weekend
I kissed you that evening
Before the eagles flew into town
And now I feel like a fool
I'm back to someone who's cruel
Back to someone who would let me down
It could've been good
I could've been yours
You could've been mine
It could've been ours
It could've been us
It could've been
Cheyenne and I
I hit you up back in may
Just to ask how you were
I ghosted you but I blamed it on school
You called me back
You cared a lot like I did
And I felt like a kid
Who was ready to break all the rules
But I'm already too late
You were soon to graduate
And magic we had fell out
And if I would've gone deaf
If I heard your voice again
I wouldn't hear another sound
It could've been good
I could've been yours
You could've been mine
It could've been ours
It could've been us
It could've been
Cheyenne and I
We left a lot up to chance
I still owe you a dance
I still owe you a shopping spree
When I chose her
I had to deal with alot
I should've grabbed what I got
Should've held on to you and me
Because it could've been love
Like the love that I felt
For the first time in middle school
But now you're far far away
And the other girl's ok
But oh we would've been cool
Oh we would've been cool
It could've been good
I could've been yours
You could've been mine
It could've been ours
It could've been us
It could've been
Cheyenne and I
It could've been good
I could've been yours
You could've been mine
It could've been ours
It could've been us
It could've been
Cheyenne and I
I could've been a bit overzealous
I guess I was jealous
Of what she thought about
I swear I could control my emotions
But all of her motions
Her movements
Her hips like the ocean
There has to be a reason I left her
Why I read all those books
How I went through the grief
Why I did all it took
There has to be
A reason I left you
A reason I left Cheyenne
For nothing new